Gatlinggunforum
General Category => D&E Specific => Topic started by: gatguy on April 24, 2021, 02:27:29 PM
-
After making 6 RGGs, I want to do a D&E now, my lathe, mills, grinder, etc. are lonesome for a project! I would like to have the do's and don'ts from you guys who have struggled thru your builds.
All replys thanks in advance.
dicksknives@aol.com (gatguy)
-
I think Sparky knows these things inside and out....
-
Although the D&E gun is a much more scale replica, it is loaded with engineering problems. Very few people have gotten one to fire reliably. Even the D&E website shows pics of a gun with bolts that are NOT made to the prints. Also, be aware the D&E gun uses 22 shorts which are much harder to find and more expensive.
I completed a D&E build to about the 75% stage when I found out about all the design problems and non functioning. I ended up using the RGG internals design, scaled down with changes to the bolts and putting that into the D&E housing for a functioning gun.
As a result of my experience and a LOT of research, I would suggest building the RGG gun and copy the external cosmetic details from the D&E design, best of both worlds.
-
It's been several years since I did my build. I wanted a functional gun that was as close to historic scale as practical. I bought both sets of plans and closely studied both. In addition a had a good set of photos of a real 1874 GG. From all this info I ended up building a half scale 1874 gun, internals based on RGG and the externals based on D&E and the photos of a real gun. It was apparent from studying the D&E design that it was not as robust as the RGG.
Joe B